Tough Congressional Battles Forecasted for Gottheimer, Sherrill

The fight to retain the congressional seats for North Jersey Democrats is shaping up to be tougher than two years ago.

The Monmouth University Poll released April 23 found voters are evenly divided between Republican (46%) and Democratic (45%) candidates in the five most competitive congressional districts—2, 3, 5, 7 and 11. 

Those seats are currently held by Republican Jeff Van Drew and Democrats Andy Kim, Josh Gottheimer, Tom Malinowski and Mikie Sherrill, respectively. All but Gottheimer won for the first time in 2018, while Van Drew switched party affiliations in January.

Unfriendly Terrain

“Democratic incumbents in New Jersey’s ‘blue wave’ districts face a tough challenge heading into November,” said Patrick Murray, director of the independent Monmouth University Polling Institute. “The terrain does not look quite as friendly as it did two years ago even with a strong performance by their party at the top of the ticket this year.”

At the same time in 2018, Democrats held an aggregate seven-point edge in these districts (49% to 42%), going on to win the seats by nine points (54% to 45%) that November.

Statewide, the picture looks positive with 50% of voters saying they will back the Democratic candidate in their congressional district and 38% who will support the Republican. This margin is slightly narrower than a Monmouth University Poll conducted at this same point in the 2018 cycle. 

Generic Advantage

Democratic candidates held a statewide 54%-35% generic House vote advantage in April 2018, which increased on Election Day when Democrats won the cumulative statewide House vote 60% to 39%. Democrats currently hold a 56% to 31% lead in the seven safest districts—six held by a Democrat—which is nearly identical to their 27-point advantage in April 2018. 

At the top of the ticket, presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden and Sen. Cory Booker hold substantial leads among New Jersey voters in their races for President and U.S. Senate, respectively. 

In the race for the White House, Biden holds a 16-point advantage over President Donald Trump among registered voters in New Jersey (54% to 38%). Self-described Democrats support Biden by a 93% to 3% margin and Independents are backing the former vice president 51% to 36%. Republicans support Trump by a 92% to 6% margin. 

Booker Looks Strong

In the race for U.S. Senate, Booker—who beat Jeff Bell by 14 points in 2014—holds sizable leads over his Republican challengers Hirsh Singh (58%-33%) and Rik Mehta (55%-32%).

Murray noted the size of Booker’s lead is not “unusual” accounting for the Republican nominee has not been decided. New Jersey’s primary will be held July 7, pushed back a month by Gov. Phil Murphy due to the coronavirus pandemic.

“The race could tighten once voters start paying attention, but that won’t happen until the fall,” said Murray. “Still, the fact that a clear majority support Booker’s reelection regardless of the opponent is good news for the incumbent.”


  1. The data presented shows the aggregate of the five contested districts. Does the Monmouth poll break the races down by individual congressional district? I would think the data has to be there.

    1. Mr. Fishman, First, thanks for visiting the website and leaving a comment. I wanted to let you know that I went back to double check and Monmouth did not make public a district by district breakdown. If they had, I would have definitely included it in our story.

      1. Thank you for checking. Would be most interesting to see the data if it ever emerges.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.