Screen Shot 2020-08-13 at 9.39.38 AM

Gottheimer Takes Aim at Senate GOP While Highlighting Clawback Efforts

Rep. Josh Gottheimer admonished GOP senators who treat New Jersey as a “piggy bank” but are balking at helping the Garden State as it attempts to recover from the COVID-19 crisis. 

Gottheimer comments came during a zoom conference Aug. 12 focusing on grants the Congressional 5th district has received since he was elected in 2016, a return 108% of federal tax dollars to the district.

“Jersey has been treated like the Moocher States’ piggy bank—by paying everyone else’s tab for their roads, bridges, and first responders, while our taxes keep going up,” said the congressman. “It’s a joke and it’s why we are fighting so hard for these grants and resources, to help even the playing field here.”

Red State Refusal

Gottheimer turned his focus on Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) and other GOP senators, calling it “a travesty” for those who have balked at including more funds for states and municipalities at the center of the coronavirus storm.

“With the latest COVID package negotiations, the fact that the Senate Majority Leader and others from Red States—from Moocher States—are refusing to help states like ours during the COVID pandemic is absolutely absurd,” he said. “We are always there for them during a hurricane, flood, tornado—you name it —and we reach into our pockets to support their families. It’s only right that they do the same.”

The congressman said he is still working to fully reinstate the State and Local Tax (SALT) deduction as well as revising transportation funding formulas in order to reduce the tax burden on New Jersey residents. The most recent House-passed relief package would reverse the SALT provision of the 2017 Tax Hike Bill.

SALT, Transportation Funding

“(Reinstatement would) stop the double taxation on our families,” he said “I’ve now helped pass two bills in the House to fully reinstate it, but we’ve been waiting on the Senate to act. Crickets.”

Gottheimer characterized that current transportation funding formulas “whack(ing) New Jersey out of federal infrastructure investment, and my Anti-Moocher legislation makes it clear that states like ours, that pay more in federal taxes, should get back more. Mississippi and Alabama get back $4.38 and $4.32 for every dollar they send to Washington and New Jersey gets back 67 cents.”

The two-term Democratic congressman noted with the current crisis stretching local budgets coupled with severe revenue shortfalls, the importance for towns to apply for federal grants has grown.

Return on Investment

“While helping lower our property taxes has always been a focus of mine, clawing more of our federal dollars back to the Fifth District is now more important than ever,” said Gottheimer. “Thanks to utilizing grant opportunities in ways North Jersey hasn’t in decades, we’re working together to lower the property tax burden on our residents and to support our local communities.” 

While return on investment is a term more commonly used in business, Gottheimer has made this a focus for the communities in the 5th Congressional District. His office has hired a Director of Return on Investment who is responsible for finding federal grant dollars, working with towns and nonprofits to apply for the federal funds.

As a result, in the four years that Gottheimer has served North Jersey, communities in Bergen, Passaic, Sussex and Warren are getting back more than what they have put in. 

$450 Household Savings

“Working together with mayors, councils, first responders, colleges, nonprofits, and religious institutions, and we are now up more than 108% in our federal tax dollars we’ve clawed back to Jersey, helping to lower our property taxes and improve the Fifth District,” stated Gottheimer. 

According to the congressman, the federal tax dollars clawed back in 2019 average out to a savings of $448 for each household in the four counties.

Among the federal programs Gottheimer highlighted include: 

  • Assistance to Firefighters Grant (AFG): Twelve towns have clawed back more than $2 million in total AFG investment since 2016. In 2019, Allendale was granted more than $183,000 to purchase 27 Self Contained Breathing Apparatus Kits (SCBAs). 
  • Staffing for Adequate Fire and Emergency Response Grants (SAFER): Approximately $630,000 in SAFER investments have returned to the district, including the Park Ridge Fire Department, which can now properly train six members of their force and the Mansfield Fire Company #1, which clawed back investment to help recruit members.
  • Nonprofit Security Grant Program (NSGP): More than $4.1 million in NSGP investment from 2016 has returned, providing grants to tax-exempt organizations like houses of worship, schools, and local nonprofits to boost security. During this past calendar year, eight temples and churches received this federal investment in Teaneck, Newton, Fair Lawn, Paramus, and Park Ridge.
  • USDA Rural Development (RD) grants: In 2019 alone, nearly $1.2 million was awarded, including Sussex Borough receiving around $1 million to combat contamination at Lake Rutherford and renovate an ambulance vehicle, Sussex County Community College was able to expand their academic programming to adapt to the demands of the modern job economy, and the Hackettstown Business Improvement District received investment for the development of a public market facility.


  1. Does the math include defense expenditures? The so-called “Moocher States” are often home to many military installations and it is likely that Gottheimer’s numbers include the expense of national defense in Alabama and Mississippi, for example. NJ is a small state with little open space for major military bases so it is understandable that federal money associated with defense ends up in the Moocher States and not in NJ. Gottheimer should adjust his numbers to back-out defense expenditures that benefit everyone or figure out how to have more military bases in NJ.

  2. “and the Hackettstown Business Improvement District received investment for the development of a public market facility.”
    What is the current status of this? Where is it planned? Details?

  3. The Democrat party platform says that income inequality is one of the most important issues affecting the country.

  4. The Democrat party platform says that income inequality is one of the most important issues. But Rep. Gottheimer’s district is ranked #13 in annual household income! That’s higher than 97% of other districts and he complaining about not getting enough money back from Washington? In effect, he’s stealing money from poor people to “clawback” taxes for his wealthy district. He’s cutting taxes for the rich off the backs of poor people all over the country.

  5. Rep Gottheimet, Ignores constituent questions I contacted him March 26 and at least 3 times a month have been ignored asked about “ Stand Alone Bills”. Josh has to go

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.