Friday, January 27, 2023
North-JerseyNews.com
  • Home
  • Washington
  • Trenton
  • County
  • Court
  • Roundup
  • Opinion
  • Search
  • Donation
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Washington
  • Trenton
  • County
  • Court
  • Roundup
  • Opinion
  • Search
  • Donation
No Result
View All Result
North-JerseyNews.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Court

Wallace Defends His Tie-Breaking Vote for Democrats’ Redistricting Map

Redistricting panel chair says Democrats map ‘more party-blind’ than GOP offering

Liz Grover by Liz Grover
January 13, 2022
in Court
0 0
3
North-JerseyNews.com
0
SHARES
204
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The chairman of the New Jersey Congressional Redistricting Commission defended his choice of the Democrats’ map over the Republican map, saying that it was “more party-blind” and incorporated more testimony from the public than the GOP’s redistricting proposal.

John Wallace Jr., a retired New Jersey Supreme Court associate justice and the Independent who broke a tie between the commission’s six Democrats and six Republicans, gave a more detailed explanation of his choice in responding to a Jan. 4 written request from the same high court on which he once served.

In his Jan. 11 filing with New Jersey’s high court, Wallace said, “I should have stated that the Democrats’ map better satisfied the standard for Partisan Fairness. I do that at this time to further support my vote in favor of the Democrats’ map.”

Tiebreaking Vote

New Jersey Supreme Court Chief Justice Stuart Rabner had requested Wallace “amplify” his explanation at a Dec. 22, 2021, redistricting commission meeting where he said his tiebreaking vote for the Democrats’ map was based on the fact that in 2011, the last time New Jersey was redistricted, the Republican map was chosen.

“In the end, I decided to vote for the Democratic map simply because the last redistricting map it was drawn by Republicans. Thus, I conclude that fairness dictates that the Democrats have the opportunity to have their map used for this next redistricting cycle,” Wallace said last month in choosing the Dems map.

North-JerseyNews.com

Republicans on the commission cried foul in a Dec. 30, 2021 lawsuit. In their complaint, they urged the New Jersey Supreme Court to jettison the Democrats’ map, contending that Wallace’s action undermined the constitutional structure of the commission and was “arbitrary, capricious, and unreasonable.”

In Wallace’s Words…

In expounding on his decision, Wallace stated that when the Democrats’ six commission members presented their proposed map, each “referred to various citizen recommendations presented during the public hearings (on redistricting). The Republicans, on the other hand, presented their proposed districts by their experts and did not refer to public testimony to the degree the Democrats did. Thus, the Democrats’ presentation helped to reinforce my decision to select their map.”

He added: “In stating that I would vote for the Democrats’ map because the prior map was formulated by the Republicans, I did so because just as the principles reflected in the Republican 2011 map produced competitive elections throughout the prior decade, I believed it would be fair to allow the Democratic principles reflected in their map to attempt to do the same for the coming decade.”

The retired judge concluded his letter to the court, stating that he voted for the Democrats’ map “for the additional reasons that their map better met the standard for Partisan Fairness and the Democrats gave a more impressive presentation of the reasons for the districts utilizing citizen testimony from the public hearings.”

Republican Response

GOP Redistricting Commission Chairman Doug Steinhardt rejected Wallace’s explanation.

“As predicted, Chairman Wallace made an anemic attempt to backtrack on a clear statement he read from a script at the hearing. The notion that the Democrats’ map is better on political fairness is as ridiculous and it is indefensible,’ Steinhardt tweeted Jan. 11.

Democrats Defend Their Map

Days earlier, the New Jersey Democratic State Committee urged Garden State Republicans to “stop undermining” the redistricting process.

“Now that they lost, (Republicans) have resorted to personal attacks on one of the state’s most respected jurists with baseless claims and false statements to support their conspiratorial ideas,” NJDSC Spokesman Phil Swibinski said in a statement.

Swibinski said the redistricting process ultimately “delivered a fair map that meets all constitutional and legal standards.”

“Rather than considering the totality of Justice Wallace’s remarks, Republicans are instead harping on a single sentence that does not fully represent the work done to arrive at this map and in the process being dishonest with the courts and with New Jerseyans,” Swibinski added.

In North Jersey, the Democratic map’s redesigned districts are seen helping incumbent Democratic Reps. Mikie Sherrill in the 11th congressional district and Josh Gottheimer in the 5th congressional district and hurting prospects for North Jersey incumbent Rep. Tom Malinowski in the 7th congressional district.

What’s Next

Steinhardt and his fellow Republicans on the redistricting panel will get a chance to say more, as will the Democrats whose Jan. 11 motion to dismiss the Republicans’ complaint remains pending before the New Jersey Supreme Court.

Chief Justice Rabner ordered Democrats to file a supplemental brief of 15 or fewer pages before Jan. 14, “addressing the implications” of Wallace’s written explanation.

He ordered the Republicans to submit by Jan. 21 an answering brief of 60 or fewer pages.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • More
  • LinkedIn

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Tags: 11th Congressional District5th Congressional District7th Congressional DistrictBreaking News New JerseyBreaking News NJcongressional redistrictingJohn Wallace Jr.latest political news from New Jerseylatest political news from WashingtonLive News New Jerseynew jerseyNew Jersey Breaking NewsNew Jersey Congressional Redistricting CommissionNew Jersey Democratic State Committee spokesman Phil SwibinskiNew Jersey Local Newsnew jersey political newsNew Jersey Redistricting CommissionNew Jersey Supreme Court Chief Justice Stuart RabnerNJ political newsNorth JerseyNorth Jersey Local NewsNorth Jersey NewsPolitical NewsPolitical News NJRep. Josh GottheimerRep. Mikie SherrillRep. Tom MalinowskiRepublican Redistricting Commission Chairman Doug SteinhardtWashington Political News
Previous Post

North-JerseyNews.com Roundup for Jan. 13, 2022

Next Post

New Jersey Lowers School COVID Quarantine to 5 Days

Next Post
North-JerseyNews.com

New Jersey Lowers School COVID Quarantine to 5 Days

Comments 3

  1. Will says:
    1 year ago

    newjersey.redistrictingandyou.org is a great place to drill down into different redistricting plans! Great article despite the frustrating topic. Should be noted that progressive groups like the lwvnj and njisj have come out against the plan too!

    Loading...
    Reply
  2. Jerard Basmagy says:
    1 year ago

    If the sixth district isn’t gerrymandering I don’t know what is. Nothing like carving out a solid block of Monmouth Republicans and ramming them in with areas North and West of the Driscoll Bridge.

    Loading...
    Reply
  3. Pingback: Oroho Call for Investigation of Princeton Gerrymandering Project | North-JerseyNews.com

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

support-Local

Recent Post

North-JerseyNews.com

Murphy Faces Criticism for Using 500K in COVID Funds to Buy SUVs

by R0bert Amoroso
January 27, 2023
0

North-JerseyNews.com

North-JerseyNews.com Roundup for Jan. 27, 2023

by North-JerseyNews.com
January 27, 2023
0

Bill Hakeem

Pascrell Condemns Republican Removal of Democratic Committee Members

by Nathan Resso
January 27, 2023
3

Popular

North-JerseyNews.com

Murphy Faces Criticism for Using 500K in COVID Funds to Buy SUVs

by R0bert Amoroso
2023/01/27
0

North-JerseyNews.com

North-JerseyNews.com Roundup for Jan. 27, 2023

by North-JerseyNews.com
2023/01/27
0

Bill Hakeem

Pascrell Condemns Republican Removal of Democratic Committee Members

by Nathan Resso
2023/01/27
3

Subscribe now

Join 100,000+ other subscribers

Select list(s) to subscribe to

ss-tp
2107.JG.FightForJersey

North-JerseyNews.com

When it comes to breaking news North Jersey, North Jersey local news or live news North Jersey, We all look for a reliable source that can give us authentic North Jersey news or local Jersey news.

© Copyright 2021 North-JerseyNews.com

Design and Developed By MOZWEBMEDIA

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Washington
  • Trenton
  • County
  • Court
  • Roundup
  • Opinion
  • Search
  • Donation

© Copyright 2021 North-JerseyNews.com
Design and Developed By MOZWEBMEDIA

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Finance-Currency-Financial-World-Dollar-Funds-634901

Add Your Heading Text Here

Pop-up Design 1 (1)

 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: