It was by all accounts a candid moment for Governor Phil Murphy speaking last week to business leaders, telling them to buckle up and get ready for the likelihood of a recession in 2023.
Murphy speaking at the Chamber of Commerce Southern New Jersey event in Mount Laurel Jan. 11 appeared optimistic throughout most of his speech until he began to warn of the economic realities facing the Garden State, telling those in attendance, “what’s around the corner is what we have to be concerned about.”
The speech began as a typical boilerplate address to the business community, with the Governor repeating many of the same political talking points from his State of the State address along with praising the work of those in attendance.
Murphy Forecasts Recession in 2023
However, the upbeat mood within the room quickly changed as Murphy bluntly explained what may lie ahead for New Jersey, predicting the likelihood of rising interest rates along with the potential of a recession in 2023.
The governor nevertheless felt New Jersey was in a good position to deal with whatever upcoming economic challenges the state may face within the coming months. Although a recession is likely, the governor believes it will be far less severe than 2008, when the country went into economic freefall because of the subprime mortgage crisis.
“Shallow Recession”
“I’m in the camp of a shallow — real but meaningful — but a shallow, fairly short-lived recession, and part of the reason I believe that is there’s an enormous amount of liquidity on the sidelines,” Murphy said during the annual luncheon.
“We all have to accept the fact when the Federal Reserve raises interest rates at the clip that they’re raising them, and (when) we’re dealing with real inflation and affordability challenges that we haven’t seen in 40 years, not only do we have to acknowledge that there’s pain at the kitchen table, but it’s axiomatic that the economy is going to slow down.”
Murphy paused a moment and then continued. “We haven’t seen it yet in our revenues at the state level. But that does not mean we’re not preparing for what will be thin ice.”
Better Prepared than Others
The former Goldman Sachs executive pivoted away from his gloomy forecast to a more positive tone, reminding his audience of his accomplishments, “we have a massive surplus, we’re reducing our indebtedness, we’re delivering relief, as best we can, first and foremost through property tax relief to ease the pain at the kitchen table.”
The governor reminded those in attendance that New Jersey isn’t facing the same issues as California’s $22.5 billion dollar budget deficit just announced by Gov. Gavin Newsom.
Murphy went on to explain that the Garden State is financially sound, sitting on $1.4 billion dollars in unspent funds, the largest surplus in the state’s history, compliments of the federal government’s “American Rescue Plan” package. Added on top of that is an estimated $12 billion dollars coming to the state through the and Bipartisan Infrastructure Bill, and millions more from the CHIPS Act.
Tax Revenues
However, that optimistic outlook according Treasury officials may be a bit premature considering that the states revenues gained through tax collections have been moderate at best for this current fiscal year.
Collections from New Jersey’s major revenue sources including the state’s sales, income, and corporate business taxes grew by only 0.5% this November over the same period last year.
The administration expects this trend to continue unabated for the rest of the year with revenues dropping by 3.2% compared to last year. Moreover, according to a recent Bloomberg poll the likelihood of a recession in 2023 stands at 70% by those economists surveyed.
Recession? Endless growth is impossible, as at this stage we have exceeded sound ecological sustainable scale. However government, not the private interest are the answer. One is based on equity the other unreasonable profits at the expense of a common good. Why can’t this Nation return to it’s roots or it’s not so far past; for example FDR’s new deal. The other would be Alexander Hamilton’s Dirigisme. Two concepts created the republic in the beginning one is absolutely required, Dirigisme the other Laissez Faire is only possible when nature’s bounty was present; nature is limited or finite. An economy that operates outside is laws id doomed to exceed sustainable scales, which we have already exceeded.
Dirigisme or dirigism (from French diriger ‘to direct’) is an economic doctrine in which the state plays a strong directive role as opposed to a merely regulatory or non-interventionist role over a capitalist market economy.Remember the more privatized our economy becomes the less freedoms and benefits of liberty we will have as a people. Government as intended, is good government, which we are in danger of losing because of private forces. A huge part of the problem is the Jeffersonian notion that “the government that governs best is the one that governs least.” While that is true as regards individual liberty, it is absolutely dangerous to think that way as regards the economy. So you see we have an upside-down republic; capitalism for the working class, socialism for the corporate powers. More tax subsidies go to fossil fuel interest, than education, health-care and defense. Money is not the problem, it’s how it is being used, the people who produce the value of money are not served by it’s value.